The Data Challenge in Agency Transitions
CMOs know this very well: one of the most complex aspects of switching agencies is managing the transfer of valuable campaign data and insights. This includes historical performance metrics, audience insights, and media buying rates that have been accumulated over years of campaigns.
Listening to our customers and partners over the years, it emerged that one of the most relevant challenges in agency transitions revolves around data ownership.
While brands technically own their campaign data, the reality is often more complicated. Agencies may consider certain insights and buying rates as proprietary information, especially when they're intertwined with broader agency learnings or negotiated rates that benefit multiple clients.
The challenge becomes particularly acute when the previous agency managed buying through their own accounts on major platforms like Google's Display & Video 360 or Meta's advertising systems. Let’s explore real-world scenarios and examples.
The Pain Points: More Than Just Data Transfer
While the technical aspects of data transfer present significant challenges during agency transitions, the pain points extend far deeper into the organizational and operational ecosystem.
One of the most pressing issues is the potential loss of institutional knowledge and campaign insights that often reside in agency-specific tools and workflows.
Brands frequently find themselves in a position where they must reconstruct performance histories and reestablish measurement frameworks – a process that can take months and potentially impact campaign effectiveness.
Another critical pain point emerges from the intricate web of platform access and permissions. When agencies manage campaigns through their master accounts, brands can find themselves temporarily locked out of their own advertising platforms during transitions. This creates dangerous blind spots in campaign management and reporting, particularly during the crucial handover period.
The situation becomes even more complex when dealing with negotiated media rates and proprietary targeting segments that may be tied to the outgoing agency's relationships and technology stack.
Furthermore, the resource drain on internal teams during agency transitions cannot be understated.
Marketing and analytics teams often find themselves caught between two (or more) agencies – managing the outgoing agency's wind-down while simultaneously onboarding the new partner. This creates a substantial operational burden, diverting attention from strategic initiatives and potentially impacting ongoing campaign performance.
The challenge is particularly hard for global brands managing multiple agency relationships across different markets, each with its own unique data requirements and regulatory considerations.
Best Practices for Brands involved in Media Agency Reviews
As first-party data becomes increasingly valuable in the digital advertising ecosystem, brands are evolving their approach to agency reviews.
They're bringing technical expertise into the evaluation process earlier and focusing on potential partners' data capabilities.
The ability to work with and enhance a brand's data assets has become as important as traditional media planning skills.
To prepare for successful agency transitions, brands should consider the following check-list:
- Maintain ownership of their platform accounts rather than operating through agency-owned accounts;
- Establish clear data governance protocols before beginning agency relationships;
- Create comprehensive documentation of data sources and processes;
- Invest in technology infrastructure that supports data portability;
- Consider data migration requirements when structuring agency contracts.
The Case for a Shared Data Platform
The creation of comprehensive checklists for media agency transitions highlights the critical importance of a unified, brand-controlled data platform.
Here's how such a platform can revolutionize agency reviews:
- Centralized Control: Brands would maintain direct ownership and access to their data, regardless of which agency is currently managing their campaigns.
- Seamless Transitions: New agencies could be granted immediate access to historical data without complex migration processes or dependency on the outgoing agency.
- Standardized Format: Data would be consistently structured and readily accessible, eliminating the need for time-consuming reformatting or data reconstruction.
- Historical Continuity: Brands would retain their complete performance history, enabling new agencies to build on past learnings rather than starting from scratch.
The ARM Solution in Media Agency Reviews
The future of media agency reviews will continue to evolve around data portability and data governance. This evolution has created an opening for specialized technology solutions, with Advertising Resource Management (ARM) platforms like MINT ARM emerging as a transformative force in managing agency transitions and data continuity.
The power of an ARM platform lies in its ability to serve as a central, brand-controlled repository for all advertising data. Rather than having campaign data scattered across various agency-owned accounts or platforms, brands can maintain a single source of truth that transcends agency relationships. This fundamentally changes the dynamics of agency transitions, removing the friction and potential conflicts around data ownership and transfer.
What makes ARM solutions particularly valuable is their ability to standardize data across the advertising ecosystem. When implemented, a platform like MINT ARM ensures that all campaign data, performance metrics, and insights are captured and stored in a consistent format. This standardization eliminates the common challenge of data reconciliation and reformatting during agency transitions, allowing new agencies to hit the ground running with complete historical context.
Perhaps most importantly, an ARM platform preserves the strategic value of advertising data across agency changes. The insights, learnings, media costs and performance history accumulated over years of campaigns remain accessible and actionable, regardless of which agency is currently managing the business. This continuity ensures that each new agency relationship builds upon past successes rather than starting from scratch.
The Role of Data Management in Shaping Industry Maturity
The integration of ARM solutions into the advertising ecosystem represents a maturation of the industry's approach to data management.
By providing a neutral, brand-controlled platform for advertising data, these solutions address the fundamental challenges that have historically made agency transitions so complex. As the industry continues to evolve, having this type of robust data infrastructure will likely become not just an advantage, but a necessity for brands managing complex agency relationships.
For brands considering their data strategy, implementing an ARM solution represents an investment in both operational efficiency and strategic continuity.
It transforms data from a potential point of friction in agency transitions into a stable foundation for long-term advertising success.
Interested in how we can support media agencies reviews? Get in touch with one of our experts!
%20MINT_539%20Trends%202025%20(1).png)
.png)
